Strong Women

There was a debate on TV yesterday around whether men are put off by strong women or not. It was fascinating to see the usual polarised responses taking place – YES – NO – OF COURSE THEY ARE YOU MORON! – etc, but what got me thinking was what exactly is a strong woman?

When you think about strength of a person it’s usually in terms of how much they can lift or pull. Women certainly like men with muscles and who can do things for them like move furniture and carry the groceries in. But is all that attractive in a woman? Do men like women who can carry bags of sand or cement, or who can lift twice their own bodyweight on a weightlifting bar? I don’t think so.

There is the view that “strong” women are the ones who know their own mind, aren’t afraid to speak it, have people jumping around to their tune, don’t take no for an answer and who fight their corner tooth and nail. Some would say that isn’t strength, that’s just bad attitude.

We can look to fictional “strong” ladies for some ideas – Elsie Tanner or Bet Lynch in Coronation Street, Dolly Levi of Hello  Dolly, Calamity Jane perhaps. They knew their own mind, were probably a bit too single-minded most of the time, but strong? Maybe.

How about famous “strong” women – Margaret Thatcher, Katie Price, Karren Brady for example. A lot of people would think they are strong, but are they really that or are they just clever at projecting that persona to survive in the world of men?

I think that the truth lies somewhere in between all of those views. Yes women have to project a bit of maleness to survive in the world of business or politics, they have to work hard at putting on a front to protect themselves from emotional hurt and damage, and yes they have to be single-minded to achieve what they want from life.

But isn’t that true of everyone, women and men alike? Everyone needs emotional strength as well as physical strength to get through life, so why would one sex be frightened off the other by displays of it? Is it that emotionally strong women discourage the protective side of men whose desire is to look after them? The reverse can be true of women, in that they tend to have the desire to “mother” men and don’t like it when men don’t need it.

Underneath the Kevlar-coated shell of “strong” women tends to lurk a very insecure interior and that shell is in place for a very good reason. So men, if you come across a woman that puts you off because she appears to have it all and be in control, yells and gives her orders, stands and fights you to the death over trivial things, doesn’t ask for comfort or support and who argue their point until you give up and leave them to it then please, just give her a moment longer to find out what it is that she’s fighting for or what she’s hurting about. There will be something underneath the shell.





8 thoughts on “Strong Women”

  1. You put it well. There are many definitions of strong women, but each of us have our own strengths and weaknesses. It’s amazing the strengths we can find when we need them.


  2. Wading in here I’m going to play the humanist card. As mairedubhtx says we all have strengths and weaknesses. A strong public character can hide a meek private character. The history of women and their fight for equality makes men see ‘strong’ women as masculine when they adopt an organised, direct approach and when they succeed in a managerial supervisory role. Personally, I don’t mind who manages me. It is a little disconcerting when I hear a change of voice tone but it helps me accept that they’re acting officially rather than as a friend, man or woman. It’s not intimidating, it’s like a code. I think what’s most important is that in any conversation about women, or men too, it’s wrong to generalise. We’re all different and bloody hard to figure out. So I don’t try. It’s actually easier that way. 🙂


I'd love to hear your view, please leave a comment!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s